%PDF-1.6
%
1 0 obj
<>stream
application/pdfEndogeneity of Monetary Policy Reaction Fun~tion: An Experiencefrom Pakistan's EconomyMonetary policy, in general, refers to those steps taken bythe Central Bank to achieve such broader objectives of the economy asgrowth, employment, external balance and price stability through changesin the money supply, interest rates and credit policies. The moneysupply thus created by the Central Bank should be in response to thechanges in key macroeconomic target variables such as GNP, balance ofpayments, inflation, internal debt and unemployment. Indeed, a properlyestimated monetary policy reaction function can provide usefulinformation regarding such matters as to whether the Central Bank, infact, has been systematically accommodating to the changes in the targetvariables. The reaction function can also provide insight into thequestion as to what should be the relevant indicators of the monetarypolicy. In addition, as argued by Havrilesky (1967), it may also play acrucial role in the formulation of long-term monetary policy strategy.The other important consideration in the development of a monetarypolicy reaction function pertains to the endogeneity of the monetarypolicy. As pointed out by Goldfeld and Blinder (1972), if a policyvariable responds to the lagged (or expected) target values, thenconsidering such a policy variable as exogenous would not only introducethe problem of misspecification but will also produce serious biases inthe parameters estimated from those models. In particular, if themonetary policy variable happens to be strongly influenced by targetvariables, then the standard result of the relative effectiveness of themonetary policy vis-a-vis fiscal policy can be questionable on thegrounds of reverse causation problem.
Acrobat 5.0 Scan Plug-in for Windows; modified using iTextSharp 4.1.6 by 1T3XTWinter 1991,Vol. 30, No.4 Part II
endstream
endobj
2 0 obj
<>/ProcSet[/PDF/ImageB]>>/CropBox[0 0 393.6 584.88]/Parent 5 0 R/Type/Page>>
endobj
3 0 obj
<>stream
q
393.60 0 0 584.88 0 0 cm
/Im1 Do
Q
endstream
endobj
4 0 obj
<>/Filter/CCITTFaxDecode/Width 1640/BitsPerComponent 1/Name/Im1/Height 2437/Decode[1 0]/Subtype/Image/Length 56286/ColorSpace/DeviceGray/Type/XObject>>stream
&[! AM=m4T{d @:869`I&ApPOVv ZVPUKa-tHX)PMe''=58%')ZB KI 8VTo U*7oViA%o>Tn"+ixOUI."AL'UQ_j]D&X a$MJ)S8uKT^S
0
;T iMhaA i?
A_``|V< HjY!pC2j'<p xm xg&@k`0.(&
ԁ%a4a0UuqPkpamp>xiN[qw!?~}^]_%OU x 9^28! A 8Ǔr Y]?O SB 2b27"zE9;!98"h4a 9d9xKzMA` Ch0'K 0P60AL
B0N0HA@
4 'l a0`M4XL!iӴtsa
BѶB{m4NѹsZ9QͰ=B9 NG'=a4{hⳀ\6,&Mtrz74qsmZAڤoJOngA6O;0OA7h&}ߤG/OqhtA7iih&O àm亂gl3svA4a=:j+Nagtm}Km[WK?Tum=t=?nti7N[iW[]$px~ֺuOO^PZw]Rot:[==,W~K{=-B>k^U▿*JPخ![z#_̓N[́~l|a#;K_vvM֟oU]unG;tAGKK}B99on+]
/[R^zּ7uj&Kb4'qrv?Q}{z_ΎW
+d#KB;NBFBGiBG+dt3Q0ia8abS a30@pd|&!Bh07&h4"M3MDCD0C528*DXB ,!7DqB"BSGA qdpC#p\BDDDDD8$R/J -0'Wƿ x%8C2CUipC <( x& M0tCA \(TMlUѻ[g|8vkI+J$d@C`zQ ~;HmbAP}? x)::c뫯믯2zi뮺뮞2,rACx= ,w.LT@aMDsd?Od.?0 N?|ffx. " CP!Y a˳2"9xCN2LsdN'c>4DB
0L00
7{zm}ޒm(Tջf{Ҥ3~>]z_?Rl3ju>&M:O?K+3UNnIim6vZ@ЧL.k^7?~>zH~}kB5CkX
^|uacP~zw*_8K>+s3^vC`6{B;Ko_8
/^jpp>}?Tz}_yXu}
_G.tA_
ׯӿ_W/OktZMUWG!KKQ,7U#
#_/}}}uDz5"?Dom?-F?Pomm־Vaw_uԷ˅]um\w__Va.[_ᄿᄿߧivnһ
}~KOWXN6ئ'i궒Uij>k'KJ8XVmobt*҈w}jYtI6N
]'iA4RxXMm$mRuIA0mAI0Ҧj
4؆wLRnƛMNia$էl'V8Ӥؤ&銨ikaЈamL
6!L&GDybWAQ0x00!\a0"ɑED ͘"
rBL` dp$"$(""""#b"""-""""?]S
Ai%OK;Iᮓa0Xn@r-+\,Ő!v `Af*_40C PaBjp2 {֍_h8zVuiᦼHhi܆`c
X< i}H*= e1E_Uޫ֟<Ah9#L EO!{ \r"2,!!hCdȳ !&CvA(ϳIC.d;Pr5"%|N2'_d/,3+֓lNa?"#@@"2 N9܂Ð<C6A
<6@$C`&
m0PM: 99ar7BHAiFB A9^a*!Jiw Am*TazH4A GaV>h:Jl#݃0TyvMÇh5Jmwt{*AmNPANikФzyWׯ+JwGީRmm]:j&_%^6tUk::^[qʲ,Afa/K A C+eCE\09K grq;Ą2N a"yH6Ȏn_0A a2P"AE&XAaA5Ua6A,Aa&
a0PM_I+sm:=s` (GTy4shG6{ši{
ڦl/94{8CG+MZanI.@H6tA[4{I)'JO ROAkW᯿KMugRg٧'_}'Ik釽8z~i;<϶_O[ux3K}m]{v/}kvt?M viu[7_W]J_nm%}SkυI5b_l5D?[[_G'?w-aXl/a)°_:MZä[aWuaV9Տ<_
_|KnCoAj
xF~O
z94Ko_uw~Kåd3?B=?
_OK뻯.^[u*Z}/R$Sm/]kޕ7DWm[+%M}ti%꿶ߵm5]}-'5OIC-/m>]Rj*Һb_bS[V!vCL%zv5iŦZiC Ӌv
Al$XA 46-l$Va7ŦM&U
(+iE!Pi%A&JT۪Mb IsMaPLST8TBLU+M{ ٟfvV&!u9ܐ0n8g j?DC=gYkqzi/7a
;#3ƃ9! hDB!#5ADDDDC#H5DDiDDDEwDDDq[IIZt-]IKI&ҭҦKm"t/BxUq˂/!1!cr#r f#\P2f@d x i2
v A`waBPMu_TiûJm4Ǣ
CD#0|Hl|@!G=u}u]uUW]]?_\.82 SpAp4Of9ȘOABAsfLr
.U|"ar)w' P+!9Vr,rC+l 2xC6c ?xA2?/@e3^<%vG`BYȖnM2dL2Qnpi40!!O4!aB!
BL!
4C!h2 dL dK>'d3@wnaKh6LA/A4B=ڨpBMچ-Sv=0C8I9 XG6XML!
V Ci-Pncgpehh pʎ:|աTqtw#66M6zIA6
ޓhP&~/i0i6;Mi[
'gԛI۪m(I8fo83l3:>m[å}?M7^WKbAJv &MBN;k뫽M]}][]vZCMM)]R=>!UBTUV+j{W]|+_tal@l4z8yci!{_V{ӿ]߾?O{PGZG#M%=ztk aWҿ/_w0Jw~Kp
?}d+w{}%`o_!_!]O_!_H"?#/\sj {v_ilNQji7iZHaݯ붓Z}kzam?-i}[Vo통u
>*XU0/UT{>(1vQ:RUJ)4oM8wIV)ڠ6iEl
65h0 '
aa0j٢ 鄩NqnA64 թ<,'ҰnMjc֚iإuNFL/Aj-jbM_+jڦ&ab=&[C3j_"!a
8aa!aD0CL Eadp$. "8"""""""b#xl>zK]+Z_jIZYם@1Ᏸ](`IpWWPa D-!C 0܁໑If
& &{S[PÇ}5UӾ$3\HA*AgQGMn]UWU__
~C|CsA 2W!=>dg!r!B4gq@>(2
f^A_'䬆&O[!;?)~`A&AaL& j0BA !q0|k}d^ a0L!ahh*=r
R90yF&MX$naty;Z9<(Gjra
NG6w$']7MH&{INZH7nAM kIRn~z>33;`
IޕaS~mtuVoW^@A'OMOMiS-־־nua|qlWkNSoj鴺k}q}^}p3p8~p?_߿נ`x_~m}X_G]uW~ޯsI__נXo
ނ%/KO+!p߭}/?___ {kvB9^tG
uk{4;~ȏ~Ҧߜk~}[z_OZi6^%[ o_֬5]{ xOuVҺ[)a:
+}_ض*ՆlSkئv4m$a6!M*m;Am\l4nAM T4lCM}Q]۴{kjv*vZՊ*}Byi!M4D-ab[L8Ni0C8x7"ãDDX@hHfa0!ᠸ!"8'qKT x }$jVZa4
C
l,DDC0eG!
Tr^@r R f 00+*&|H6¨T
ª__8wp?vݬ@m0@ x,
9 gǯTQOwUU\%i@V!r5:'S 9
k4N!j.
@@S ppnx^A!8e4YC|B.5Y.P30y<G
`_~T2:4fd6Avr8!,yD>! DXdEa0Oa]x &a0BA???>M}ҾONۤ^~A`l&'V;M>][ WuwWůvU*k.Ɵwin<_CU뺷_\1_}W/V}!v뿽^?V_y859^x`/~aOk_0_]B{6_^^qz/{^\6P__UvO-o<6v}.ߥ+/_l?HKW ֗Iw!VD{SC;_֛{oikiok_z{ե_Zki}&JSNmozRݮV|SiUlRkk~IS`TյM6)@ib8iEb&S@nhm&a4i
04Ab٣I0Aa$mGӫI]a$6M.M0OM,qILZwvGM'Lm;4_bf4.e;#A@=dqS?C84Ͻ422:D*i_Q I<
TC.h0L agІ0CS07 $
4DDg2M0Dg0B"!2:@DX"""">"5""8""#^ZZ@3^?~ץTӇTp Xa"?9Ð<`2YbdVC$5` n9ci
. ǮN_W!
CǣwFp s uv
aaDx^C0rIR>>qz[믷/WALu!}U|_W_MWKQd0=p<;)d0! 09nq
7! 2(-ȴ!fa-"LG
&JJn[=28"N30#~EB̆gl!;W7@ȟ2,d2eN@AGdxx; Bah dC
-B(Nj ij
BT{
B -Z904shjm}.OTr68,:g06^%Ga#
Z<itqtm apng߄ 4m'{à[6t}&I>z|?{I߭+u[m6V?IWg<}'tK +<>OҶꓳc7\& mҽnߧvߧkojuBWkFoi}zmn?mkwnЅ_Go,W}HW\WXs/kpݣE:
x_A|/\+o֫_t}o_I\-/@=_/7rG9pp_]kKނ/_/AmuBUx}I~W!_{/$/z97X~÷zkZ忯~^!ޚm/]/K_VuVhW}^0zmt+N)_ ]Jwvwz[[a{_n[^+)mSZ
MlLM3?AaBhE!!h0`0CB"hCB"a@4"L"F8hEԎa4!,' DX`B!3
ha"""""""""#uүIx`W 0ۈ`7|6AY @gd20pASL& @%h
UOO L?n
M6w;SMUoA6l Sd(2}҉]߅WAqL{F֯}Ruu__
%h2
,w!<"]1rpA;?dO .("ςfRn|ϳO6k# ˲ fa;<GHBP'49Bdhe1/Ȱn!O^B`@lvjq;P T
WP& a<( xO0L `Ax&Bh0pT!n/TB
:/-S^Jk;^o4/w ZRI;z|4ᄓ[[[ vt |wZ~ŦiIkl\i݅WvJ
Bi5;ImOJ!XN.6ҴqjM6)զ.
07 a,&I؇ m5
`Ql0& զh[ 4jmXibi=kO_4U0
+1LW
)tqLSM3E3Ea;4GD ݭM3yx0GL!aMf!gp"MB`)|,X &=""AQ`&a"XL 0La""""""""28y<4!ƿZKM-jXY,9
@mC 3 xaY L P[L'
/TÃӇk}vO<k xe#$]u]}t__A; s;4 հ{tԴ'VKiI:i
.-opaH;}:=?WM>tzmN}v4iv?ЏzدûJ+jwxB!w?_a^ll?`<
1j~
?*ޫmގ{o#_^rm%7o xoޗa'!~
8l?Bp^BB+BGBG߆O]^L6q3ޗ8{_ֿIߵ[Hka{[%_[%m,}m{wiVT{}m+IյK^ZItӵm6턷^V*u\UqVi+J)oMNiNl\[Ӎ7qH8jIqM鱧{MZ
4&a8:&Q
00baaCX44 èM;MW4Xi5LBfi-S3f} ڊkh0ªfh34L8*&> n& aB2B!!h0 E$D0LGA ЈDDA!@< d!eY(2-`A`Ap AxAA
f{K_p3:ޓ3Ap3?Rl3/6? [l'm*nڿOM~7i? aOM^OMSCu[?[o-}[W[_ivf?߯RKou_Wk
_.]/_KB 0?wW}#o]|#u/ W^A? !Gb}Z/ZQ!!{AO
8?+vz^DoZo]-um{_unK[JMw]uҵm/_[]n-Czl'wk}uka{UӊՊ~XlUi'l\S
ui1iM4鴓Mm:m+wg;i]6vt;)fѴZ>P
tjNi v6PiO60|CAVMa;VA9
y&Dqaa#0FN!a a 0"AhD4"C""""""""4"#J8,~zimP?)
2Q
CUC C.
C^yd2NA*A{ < LfS
*i
Aa;OUPU_u};X;Ӌ><AqĂ?I뿮36Jy6y? 'CA0Ah* R#G!,~ d(Y!.?. M
R~
(NrimMWT{}O0yH5fכowH6 mMnMmvQvi4Ow4zm'l8gM?imM?SuoU<ostzz꺼u}K::_!*jHuqm(ߨxƭկk]_5uiU_^Z{?mo_}ku8^p[Jpayanl1
/}7}~+^_>:pF_7w6_Zm}Z^ὴ&B
/l
/{!o_wd#aӪ$}z/$OڿAý_?/
V[ȱy_=om?{o~ײ Z]^jo߯{Mlt[]=O/M1IWkmWk%փ)0ji
;KUU+ 1I],XAij1jڭzΤmH4MNA8kNi4V\0Pb&i
(k 4tQP&L6)SMwiV݊k]m;M0M4kMAfi3Ii54L&4ih3 3A@ =E>0we0D0'(!x)CB"PP4"G aa hG`a0AHDB"!"""!DD8",k!8B""KI.k@)a
ء0uM4eX dVA</d!n2 ZӰPTo0!Tw.hMp_6Xp0øm
Dzg
n@'ϗh V}{]}oW֚TUTTU =j ;4[<TlnC'nBZBYN2r#PSٰCA
fg
NxLg' K7D08G0<DD*9;D y7J E90D2
!`O4lFOP@ d^?MC?`B 0M5!} l(BѴ=O?0Lj|C0Ba-0L&XAAznuVGBQ!ag94-MAXW8K7n]'oG+ rag $q Z68=q8[T7+J$}n7A?][.IxPڷZϽ< ꛨK}: y1?m:[A7c`N_C{}%}z}=ZCWUҷu[5{8\uxZݧ!w;3{Bx_#G HB__jj}|-6OK/__[࿏qoaG#K_q<_#ִoA$r^]wZI{֗wW7~v7VK]?b!GxWQ^sxoK7#:~Ɏ
=}]o_!]kww;Ku_[Jlկnm+RamT_JV߿~w
&I}mR(k%<Suݪvvjwݪv8wii4Abi(vhm)"wh@|@+AqQU_UTC$c
Aw@N!ȞCB!fq"^@'r
R1@8+@c\r
CG, Cd2!X! Fۄm0PMl8pUFQBiMapG/dA'Im$O$Al:S~aw_H=6
67P: ~m5>O|aJZM៌g]wi'p3>Knm