%PDF-1.6
%
1 0 obj
<>stream
application/pdfCausality Tests and the Relative Effectiveness of Monetary andFiscal Policies in PakistanThe Granger and the Sims causality tests as applied to annualdata from Pakistan for the period 1971-72 to 1989-90, help us inarriving at identical conclusions even though in the former test growthrates of the relevant variables were used and in the latter naturallogged and filtered variables were used. Both tests detectedunidirectional causality running from monetary variables (monetary baseand money stock) to nominal GNP in Pakistan for the period under study.Both tests also suggest that there is unidirectional causality runningfrom nominal GNP to the total government expenditure in Pakistan for theperiod under study. The findings of the study suggest that changes inmonetary variables do exert their influence on economic activity,represented by the nominal GNP, in Pakistan. The results of the studyalso provide some evidence that changes in total government expenditurerather than causing changes in the nominal GNP in Pakistan, are ratherinfluenced by the changes in the nominal GNP. Thus, the findings of thestudy suggest that the monetary policy was relatively more effectivethan the fiscal policy in influencing the nominal GNP in Pakistan,during the period under study.
Acrobat 5.0 Scan Plug-in for Windows; modified using iTextSharp 4.1.6 by 1T3XTWinter 1992,Vol. 31, No.4 Part II
endstream
endobj
2 0 obj
<>/ProcSet[/PDF/ImageB]>>/CropBox[0 0 384 584.88]/Parent 5 0 R/Type/Page>>
endobj
3 0 obj
<>stream
q
384.00 0 0 584.88 0 0 cm
/Im1 Do
Q
endstream
endobj
4 0 obj
<>/Filter/CCITTFaxDecode/Width 1600/BitsPerComponent 1/Name/Im1/Height 2437/Decode[1 0]/Subtype/Image/Length 54613/ColorSpace/DeviceGray/Type/XObject>>stream
&[
YA
zHA7bB ' la
N@WI쁨ap& ^dZKnO_KVS_ת_'#Hh!$2 r3@<~MJFb/7AGej
0BBM0hb-7QCn*7ݏKTďT#^tm]*Un/>wJ^^5.K-R8]zUKT*WkUKk]W_j^]kUU߭/]u]tTϔzkK@jT~Kф
/APE:\KAJ_uI:⫨b*"fhHե=) pfUWLLXU3Iz!O;M4L ia4ªCB"""""""""""""#c
p>?@w |9n
1n <l&
()0LL%<p@B|;}Z`A xk,Hޟ `zi]l=uU x`rA|3 d. r
c
1d dX>!,=D>Cpph8dBX 4 %%Z d~C죄
n ȰBL/ 2-W4̉2
8!D;d>"aC ''Ĉȟ2${(|)uxLL!lh 4 *m7naSMC(L.`;L!a0< a4!CO:6l-#*6m4q!ha
v l+NG'GK-iBˣsB9B:GMQͰG*=|37ҰamI'I,?Lh&A?Tt6it&Aߛyvnz6nn_}r#tmm=o_i{jvڭ%}گJ^ukh սaIS;_4[tMS]$&vSe:l4WI46M88tlWl\w[ظ6.4b&I~I6ilpl$
Aa6Am1lEa$m>M0ia4ݦJZ4JPLZiծGA3 E8i0i3i
3DAfa4ޢR&0oVڶn)[bXB"B-0A!"!
0 -DC9BˠB,D3ABA3$ .M3DC~A&DDDDDFDhDDDDDDDDDDqC#8)!
]DDDDDuOs03`̊8]x<@ȮBC,rrv˂8Q!0 CAZ
iaL0!a `0@02/N ;0A(@0@0Lp ia]8pA-GP9Qg
mFaQގmB9BjTqQдs-Q4-MGO$<<9-Ba
nXApz<8J=H;'A; [+nw(MzoXA MZl:ûݍ;7tW>?Am':N~xpԡ?$'On&ӇyOxzmե5VNNN'ڦm=j:?:U^[<}ŽIjkCZZn6nBÇ%GQ xK_4_ۡ\WoxXl?Z̓`E\9#/^6?:¦{L?*~o{G[__~GzA=h.A4zu{hvl7=}Z}u퐣d+ݐ>a/9ui#ҭkq~aOἂkii6Jmzۥ{-}#~Lw_үi-{n_Oׯ4?Ww]k]k%W%+ﲇ]ڰﰶm?z}MiiUmZC9<4'cM64㳻iڱMߪULCN*yVSM!iMmI
Sj 7h!niNIZt6Ӱ
M9>iԘa-8imqih?"
F[?HB3Bރ
)Sa3I4ԏlNS3?ZuUqO{QMj0;
د,\ЅB \!r)\4!!"!"AMAa`YtD4"L4
A3p!d|!g=L!!FDE!0X05ޡG/)U -K
.`0QT@m0r# h< I,A*+!d)
R
[ 2JM{L"uPÃ%}Ѻ9nOvA}^!c*>G! EEGOm}W_}WWmH.By-'] k"~Bqi|BY9α!'xBqP+(!mP=HkdiqH;0A*a0L 0&C `&
uM8
A qds '/aN֓n} N zI6u
Mcl OxM\ݞ?|W##C/כ0aPOmU_ij7
x\/Џ`GY\?Z9{q}o.WW_97Otm/!_+!]R/*w{+y8o!{W?u'o_{[tpޫIijB=ckwB;jޛ{݄_wukim$=uWm~ﰕv[iűJkl[iݧM4N;+״>0[Պm/ &5h !mMxOnH4ӆ7bvq4mrxZiZ a4ӊMӦO٢ j¦)Zfǰmq[֜l+Oa[ݺijSmZi!m5
"!a "B!`03 jc 3-XgA AT"$0AA?i`A4BS"""""""""DDDVG"" `DA!9C;aB!&Ga!"""""""":_#<hULR,$`a*Cj@ׂ<{!
C @k9@kF0AB y8&
RjTw A#TgoOMSis5=QAD(A
N# 'AV@}HAn&Lw ?aFɹak_. O
'$0_}+Jk]kU=:_qӭUpj_O!i! \td3LA_! ^BV8$&NsO3&?mh]uҶ}<;:]?NBmtW}^-k]ƭ]]z/_:m5ah_a']P_O~GclCGz8Vco}l[`[}bCZ_Ooߧ!_!#/-/Wo!_[!_^AD~÷"^
M^JWW]ZI~za_ӰޑC&պa+l.iRQjڧil5bM>5 [uWZ0Mb=*\ M m'AAr|5iL4
٣IAѨ %'m)ӤnMŧe<$ۤ
Ma$ iP6ئҦ~bZa(M6iTcjՍbL LSh[H^Aa{C(vG
"B3
gfpဃD8a0"
QȮv"A3>5PAC4i|Fy4"""""A# 8aC<!˘AXA`X !GqDDDDX! fVI7X}xt4pRh23i6'ë].?{?V'zU,!^kO_MA|zu[< 7<.vxEi;uxoIi_t{kݭuM{]0_:zCW߯o-7B>a ahFGдᡰGDpC
=!? ""#""""""""""""""3e")B028HeC4"""!ץ-j*)%KPcD@5C6<|EhC x-@x!p@ˀC 7frASd6<(&C(rciYY+ kz2yDpC`kD$
GOfiNa
BmA;uFZpQ 7kpXlvOߠ8@6i>ҲWj MI7tR]?'WޟMRzu|q
09@5ZNAx?@Ȕ! G2$X7ʙ"zk"D[vC̅r#(9"98 Ci?!ܝ̙s!ACdvA89vJ0BV LK&XP- o` 醹A`Xa#i&Ad A6g
#mumաp`yF!iѶPp$MUhIgh
GM#sB96jsjG6izIIҾ[tIޝ[گ A&&A?sIZNj្O>t&=3k>V|kpM,8g$۪p៌־C]zt8]7M]kooI//|]I:OM;\ ^;|k\m8خwu_]uޱVGGAW?-zNpկo_Wl3']umRW})b4au_
~ˢ7>o]B~M%_M/*ւ7~WGZG+z_߮q[|7~_m㻻t}rp퐏
Aݲ_w}+}u_گO7}"$iVi~}i'~%
(MUr8~&2vp`4+ޓzI&!XMSu[O}a/ii'bM0'{qii&z+KUU⓻N-SNj}M;buCM0.NO !M ᄚM6-6)0MJ$ }U4a&
4nM8pih6UH4i0 #Q&c#< 2B0bL@?&~ ;?0['I1Uq ڭMlAOӱ]1NwDDDA$phDXA"!
dp<+`a+SȏhGhDXB"",&D0B!B"!""""#ADHj{i~)K_tJ
3ҫ% ZB xs6h0L,DD!
,AA`HeC 5w!㑹LLG ۈ2e_aS
uTozomAI `veӴN>)ߦ7b"2>;P>
cڪޯ<12 2d˲2XC
tP3ᜠC0.6!-IG.'O
\C12#dvCxC3 09˲h"̃1˂:'p(Br%O2( 䜆3"9raC+#ȃA#4Aa`A.CpAa ^&a A
!ahGG2>0j; LCc0MxxAhml!hQ<)96pA5FZ6g6B£|3{hZhZ9(BsɣsGZ[<(FT-q4B$axM A<^w&qi6>VqoITh'IuM ukJOyjgI3NOV>&m&~>3f{IÆKI?0zl3斡|8fjtPuXx^i?]>50=-WNWC]i=[ z
}I~?{װ~.u<4~a/F_Oxv-+_O^֖M"^+kC
//ula6_[pA~/b
_j͈
>^_ua{{߄szs_-o'K
OB6o!7_OKpAҿ
!KW7d+^B8}_1ވwniaB}\"p됃gvK]o7}K_}ҿ._mKv껽K~L4/mn[V]Vo_ՆJmm0&ǴVSKIviYbSM;J☦GQsi&WIΆN;Ma8a$hC]A l$N V-!a8i1&p&iPa0lZmNNm(4jM ih>NOjm0 ie
gJ)S(M4S3TwwfjNbiwڊmv,DB""Em"B"B!&IpaahD0!
SBAЈa2>DHg! hZaAb"""""""""#8 pHHK_X`0K)ph0AX!]-Ð6q2CT|2<0 F< ¦+\@ބ3)
!d xoE x^ x5@()Ht,Ui몪ivAiMB!BjA|T@
G`pLZI0n|aWS
t;njntz
AWW+
<3^x-5%kڪ>pwUomp{&]$>%u<H'1~K-H|MB]PA'\tԆ#rNPK@k
p @# h0M| 8a"YX*{ =0h2vCD[6Bp4pRp# @ѠCy i%D9pGOt~;}84y0
G&oaY80A0ҽy0 l8
aa4B
kLaB`Nׄb>wtxMmnnMOMm{Sn^mXH
B4mG&M6
&ӣm4z֘^T2v6kI}Ѿlm%ޓ/l:|҄=;~-ZMǠ/o{]Sp-봿a$6
al ^]7ӥlwIjҸ(~uJڤ\2N*]iU~K|/{ۯozK
_ҫ)
Hωzx*u_pl߅goBU>4_莗X![^ڥ^
`zpB<#'PKOqFk-G]х6{a?$muh oA߄ugtW>SνjgJݤ4]xg7IՅS/ytf{ݙME:tMzVO<,_=? l'a=?O ۴C>ot/к[_+qݵ:7tX]ou_vҜGBt_Z*k^vk
m̓GGn-zzhgi|.mu&
}}
w4ed=/}9#sWi{oxoAU?[_ׯC
?!;!Gô}otOPi|Wy
퐎^$S]#IwKȱuWYn֛ /TڈM1NWL& M{A!nӱNU};k+[Xb
!!3l0HD06`L ЈaFpЈB!""m<Ћ=aEg "3DFDDDDGm/ko[^@sM"+
m%NXtS^#[ ""?@ x# He@( E/dnf9=#`0LSM45_TmuU\(_'In9oim5
d
'hSr*$6ݥ(EvOQG_몪2Mn99CC
q!?k</# 9C@#aGS3hCp`B
(
hen4g)s0bAJ 4]f@3^6\9x# 9f3 !=2;"I!% L@hq4PA0MBah&0P0BA&a4M B
AAd~&F2UL jZ
¦(!ag8B£u
rsmmjvxg:8a460HGXN6⣊ EͰйrhi8uۛmF煞TmqQ9SG&ۄ? iꃤ~o6}ީ'tVҶOnH7 ޛ:Mnvx%}m&mt|M<^uto>g|W>*fsIatpoޟQWotyCOjZtv8=]wִmS_ӫ~CHRI
CB?C}_mWOb0unt;yH.;S%J}҆_%JU{Ȏi
߯|5Gl2/"Çu_#t_j?n]oۆ6tlRZ
uw6Q섌WQÇ
d([["?1Qn\t[t!8nOm.o7{m/m'_Kۣ;oC__I]W_zv___mL504_TثVNﵨN**ӊbbm$Vx`6IR{k!a4l$M0N7iAMJtAӴMCVipIvPM6aiIյbإO(1UJ]ӦFqIƛVH4$M1Ja+Q5}ga41Čy IaaM
_0qA4"M3Gh77ca3(A dp@L fh)Mb""""""""""""ADDDDDDDFdpDDC!|B˃`!0L8z@
=uh'GXX!A@AmAqdd( ^)@PW!AX &`a0M4 `dxU x,\-v*OOAoA(wi 2;NC ;Б ~a9
wq x5?nuUu]UuW_}W\-wvd"9 3fEWtNrgo2|\G|30bg.͌faLF.!<
N' S ٱ]\!
b DxfyC2!,CD
aGC? h0PA&
#P/A& 0`Ѓ `); j a4y,8
J6Qɇ<5VGi4CG66P! Z9xCZjZa5XM4q=YarmTsaX 'vPN~WڠݧA6tMq+xj&nnA6䰓Vմ;>p(*~3mv't4ᙻZN
}j3>/a5-դz}ua:M_[< &WvAONӵq]uֿ\u-v.^C}_~_-|wK?zWPx߾6
?^K+úu_?!}o`9a_ׯco_~=?z^ox_ޢw_uy}^#[m>?/'oW}{xAu8nĿq[[{u}KzG_ݿB7ۯݯE/-]{W3ow,w?m'kdX{U^oҷm+}Dp<ڶ[_i0M݄ҿa. hXi/_CSt<æ'ia?~;{t4;wvqIҧvX[N-8⯶ӵ^_@<.iZr|4AM1ml%IN
L&iIiiᤚh64]
4i{4A;LS3IhU^m&اai5=5m6|Wzxa000L ahD0B!-aa"a!
08hD4DXA4,g BLd|&恢qeB"Hq`,DDDDFx2H!e!
ׯp%b\ X`b#2P!nAlAdL(@m<a#+ x oA
O!a{ xK5 *<0za
uG]S
7QjKIwv5Ӈ|
ᅴClvT]_Uݰ@ x:
kvA&A24h`/̅qrdYhC*
PaDP303y7IX!(jy"^E2:E.3
ahS0h3("DpãqL%
B\Jn%34 B pa!A0T!
B(R|a:a.0AaXACAB i`TmqѶHGG:9$4lڣ6IfG&Hhh6*9X$R6BѶPMG'GMGEۦt'A7&ۮTInn&{Imi7N'Fw ߤʹnߴ>8֩:_6tJo]㊷+U|'_Q_BC۵